Peer review

2020-06-07 → 2026-11-09

Rebuttal#

Doing a review#

Studies on peer review#

Does peer review work?#

Reviewer matching and algorithms#

AI in peer review#

Incentives and credit#

Peer review protocols#

Peer review biases#

Demonstrations of Bias in peer review:

Zhang et al. (2026) add a multistage-journal view: associations with institutional prestige, team size, topic, country, and author gender are generally stronger in editorial review than later peer review.

“Reviewer #2 is not the problem. Reviewer #3 is.”

Experiments#

Replacing journals#

History#

Articles#

Receive my updates

YY's Random Walks — Science, academia, and occasional rabbit holes.

YY's Bike Shed — Sustainable mobility, urbanism, and the details that matter.

×